As OKC Dave has pointed out KenPom.com has a really great historical player comparison feature. It takes current players’ seasons and compares them statistically to an historical college basketball player.
Here’s a full explanation of how it works.
You have to pay money to see this feature for each player, but at $20 for the entire site, it’s more than a bargain.
For the sake of time, just know that any number below in parentheses over 850 means the comparison is a pretty good one. Anything over 900 means the comp is basically the exact same player. Under 850 is all right, but not super strong.
Here are the OSU player comparisons so far this year:
Marcus Smart
Comps: ’08 Nick Calathes (857), ’07 Javaris Crittenton (848), ’13 Archie Goodwin (839), ’10 John Wall (837), ’08 James Harden (836)
Notes: Are these good players? ’08 Calethas was insane: he averaged 15 points, six boards, five assists, and two steals. That Florida team was pretty average — made the semis of the NIT.
Le’Bryan Nash
Comps: ’11 Durand Scott (889), ’07 J.R. Blount (888), ’08 Donald Sloan (880), ’09 Kwadzo Ahelegbe (880), ’12 Gerard Coleman (876)
Notes: This says it all, no? Who the crap is Durand Scott? He actually wasn’t as bad as his no-name status implies. He averaged 13-4-3 on the ’11 Miami team that made it to the third round of the NIT. Not a superstar but a scorer nonetheless.
Phil Forte
Comps: ’08 Jeremy Hazell (864), ’13 Gary Harris (855), ’07 Barry Stewart (854), ’13 Reggie McAdams (852), ’13 Kellen Dunham (851)
Notes: One of Jeremy Hazell’s future comparisons was Marshall Henderson. So, yes, if you’re asking I absolutely cannot wait for Forte to start dishing middle fingers and mind-bending shooting performances in the next few years.
Markel Brown
Comps: ’06 Adam Haluska (915), ’08 A.D. Vassallo (906), ’12 Drew Crawford (894), ’12 Chase Tapley (893), ’09 David Gonzalvez (893)
Notes: Haluska was actually in the league for a while and currently plays in Israel. He was a one-time all-freshman team Big 12 player for Iowa State (before later transferring to Iowa). Here’s his picture, him and Markel look a lot alike.
Mike Cobbins
Comps: ’09 Will Martell (891), ’10 Will Brown (880), ’11 Jeff Robinson (878), ’12 Dartaye Ruffin (873), ’10 Ralph Sampson (869)
Notes: Whoa, Ralph Sampson! [Googles Ralph Sampson '10 and realizes this is hall-of-famer Ralph Sampson's son Ralph Sampson III]. [Throws keyboard against wall].
Phil Jurick
Comps: ’13 Daryl McCoy (783), ’12 Miles Plumlee (780), ’08 Joey Dorsey (773), ’08 Kurt Looby (765), ’11 Gary McGhee (761)
Notes: When I think antonym of Phil Jurick I absolutely think “Joey Dorsey.”
Kamari Murphy
Comps: ’06 Goran Suton (891), ’13 Joel James (878), ’09 Terrance Saintil (870), ’09 Tyrell Lynch (861), ’07 Demetrius Jemison (860)
Notes: I really like the Suton comp. He didn’t do much in ’06 (his freshman year) but eventually he evolved into one of the best rebounders in the country.
Kirby Gardner
Comps: ’12 Donley Minor (886), ’11 Larry Drew (867), ’08 Andre Gilbert (863), ’06 Julian Betko (861), ’13 Jordin Mayes (858)
Notes: Larry Drew was the backup on that ’09 Carolina team that won it all. So I’ll take that.
We’ll revisit these for fun later in the year.











--
Welcome to Pistols Firing

reading this resulted in me asking the same question to myself over and over. ‘who the F are these people?’ Smart was the only interesting player comparison (because i have heard of those studs he’s compared to)
Scott, I agree…the cool thing on KenPom’s site is that you can click on the comparisons and see what kind of career that player had. The site is definitely worth $20 if you are a college hoops fan.
Here are the current OSU versions of my similarity rankings. I’ll list 3 former players for each current one:
Smart: Tony Allen ’04, Tony Allen ’03, Brooks Thompson ’93
Brown: Terrel Harris ’09, John Lucas ’03, Adrian Peterson ’99
Nash: Markel Brown ’12, Corey Williams ’92, Victor Williams ’02
Forte: Glendon Alexander ’00, Adrian Peterson ’96, Joe Adkins ’99
Cobbins: David Monds ’07, David Monds ’06, Marshall Moses ’09
Jurick: Marshall Moses ’09, Matt Pilgrim ’11, Kamari Murphy ’13
Murphy: Matt Pilgrim ’11, Alex Webber ’97, Ibrahima Thomas ’08
Gardner: RW McQuarters ’96, Tyler Hatch ’07, Nick Sidorakis ’10
EDIT: Markel’s 2nd comp is John Lucas ’04. JL3 played for Baylor in 2003.
RW McQuarters…funny. Did you also check to see if anyone compared to Adarius Bowman?!